Homeopathy has benefitted greatly through the further development of homeopathic philosophy from the practice and study of contemporary Indian homeopath Dr Rajan Sankaran.
In ‘The Spirit of Homeopathy’ (1991) Sankaran describes how rather than analysing cases in a mechanical rule-bound manner he found that a “remedy represents a particular situation and that each patient’s state comes from a particular situation in the past, in which the components of his present state were necessary”.
Chapter 6: Health and Disease: Psychological and Philosophical Considerations
“Disease consists of two parts: generalised disturbance of the whole organism and localised problems. It can be seen that generalised disturbance (which includes physical, general and psychological changes) precedes localisation of the problem. this generalized disturbance is probably what Hans Selye (the authority on stress) described as the General Adaptation Syndrome. The whole of this generalized disturbance or change can be understood as a posture of adaptation for survival in a particular situation. It is obvious that if the situation does exist or is intense enough, such an adaptation would ensure survival and therefore, cannot be treated. Conversely, if such a situation does not exist, or is not proportionately intense, this general adaptation would be a maladaptation and needs to be corrected.
Disease as a posture
In sum, disease is a posture, a state of being, which is suitable and appropriate in a particular situation, a situation that does not exist at present. Disease originates from severe situations which demand this posture or state of being for survival. This state leaves an impression which we call a root which gets activated later on.
Disease sets up several conditions for feeling OK. When we imagine a lion is chasing us we will not feel OK unless we are running. In the same way, if your disease originated in the situation where you needed to achieve in order to be loved or to survive you will not feel OK unless you achieve. These conditions restrict your being in the present and your reacting to the situation appropriately. The miser’s constant need is to check his purse. He will do this even when visiting the Taj Mahal, rather than admiring its beauty.
Disease is a restriction of vision, it is a narrow way of looking at things. Only awareness of this delusion can remove it, just as light removes darkenss. Delusion disappears only with awareness.
All this talk may sound esoteric and theoretical unless the reader looks at himself in the light of what he has understood so far. If you honestly look at yourself, you will see how you feel uncomfortable in many situations and how you cling to certain roles in which you feel OK. These situations in which you feel OK fulfil your conditions for feeling OK. You are compelled to act in a particular way even though some other type of action is appropriate. In most situations you have the option of deciding how to react, but always you almost choose to react in just one or two ways, no matter what the situation is. This fixed type of reaction, compulsion, comes from the fixed way you view yourself and the situation in front of you (obsession). Both the obsession and the compulsion come from the perception you have of yourself in the situation; this is your basic delusion.
Somewhere in the past or in earlier generation you will find that somebody had gone through a situation which necessitated this kind of behaviour. You may find more often than not that you were conceived when one of your parents was exactly passing through such a state of being, or such a situation might have originated sometime in your childhood, especially from the circumstances in your own family.”
‘The Spirit of Homeopathy’ was followed by ‘The Substance of Remedies’(1994) and ‘The Soul of Remedies’ (1997) which conveyed the innermost feeling of remedies which he had observed and confirmed in his own practice. Here is a short part of his description of Arsenicum:
“The Arsenicum patient sees the world as threatening, chaotic. He feels that he is old, weak and defenseless, and that there are thieves all around him, ready to take advantage of his weakness. He needs people and is dependent on them because of his weakness, yet feels that they cannot be trusted, that they are interested only in his money. However he cannot do without them, and hence is very careful that he should not offend them, lest they leave him and go away. He is mistrustful and suspicious, cautious and anxious in all matters: money, relationships, even health.”
Dr Sankaran has continued to develop his observations of the central disturbance and the determining characteristics of groups of remedies and are read with interest by homeopaths world-wide.